I have to say that I was relieved to hear those girls sing last night. Renewed my hope in the season! My picks for the guys yesterday were more picks of what was best among what I had to work with. Last night my picks were for actual TALENT because I finally saw some!!!
Stephanie Edwards won my vote first off. WOW that girl can sing! What a way to open the night! I was super impressed (and in pain) with her ability to slam down onto her knees like that in heels and a skirt! And then she got back up with so much grace! You go, girl! I like her. She's spunky and sassy and she can sing.
And then I really liked Sabrina Sloan. Thought there for a minute it might be the night of the S's for me. She was excellent. I really enjoyed watching her have fun out there. I used to be leery of people who came in as professional singers - I'm not sure if I thought they had too much experience or if I thought since they were already singers, they should leave Idol to those who didn't have a chance otherwise or what, but by last night I was just so desperate for real talent, I was happy to see Sabrina!
I've been a fan of Melinda Doolittle since auditions becuase she was SO GOOD without being SO ARROGANT. I loved her last night. After her comment about how far it truly is from the background mic to the main mic, I thought she owned it nicely. And yet she was so grateful for the feedback! I really like her. She's a nice girl with a great voice and she deserves to go far.
And rounding out my top four (yes four today!) is Lakisha Jones. That girl rocked! I wasn't sure I'd like her singing a Jennifer Hudson song because I can't stand Jennifer Hudson (I respect her talent but always found her to be very full of herself during her Idol season). Then I remembered I've never heard Jennifer sing the song, so who cares whose song it is? You go, Lakisha!
My surprise of the night was Gina Glocksen. She was the sole contestant I had an opinion about before the start of the 24. And it's not a favorable opinion. She's struck me as someone who feels she's owed another chance, when I think she should be grateful for it. (That may not be the case at all - it's just how she comes across to me.) Because of that, I was prepared to write her off last night, but she did a good job! She might win me yet.
WHAT IS UP WITH RYAN AND SIMON? I thought they'd calmed down until Simon accused Ryan of wanting a date with whatever girl that was (I wasn't impressed with her song, so I don't remember who she was.) Good for him for saying that didn't deserve a response, but WOW the claws are out between those two this year!!!
And finally - I agreed with Simon (as I often do...just don't like to say it) that the dog walker seemed out of her element - like she was trying too hard. OH! And Hayley Scarnato did sound old with her song. I like that song very much but she sounded like a beauty pageant contestant - too much vibrato and not enough spunk. When Celine spunks a song, you can't unspunk it and expect it to sound the same.
So there - Phats, I'll go see what you thought now!! Christina?? Any thoughts this week?











