Well after loving last week's Idol music, this week's didn't really do much for me. My favorite part of the night was listening to what Jennifer Lopez had to say to them...and wondering who her favorite is. Wish she would tell!
* Melinda. I agreed with the judges that it wasn't her personal best night. However, contrary to her own opinion of herself, I think she did a great job delivering the song and it was very smooth. I loved her dress. I thought it really looked classy on her. And even when taking the criticism from Simon, she was graceful!
* Lakisha. The song was fun, although I felt like she was rushing to keep up with it. I hated her dress. I thought it wasn't flattering at all. But I still thought she did a good job. I thought she raised her game from last week.
* Chris. I didn't see any of his performance. I only heard it from the other room. I wore my strappy heels ALL DAY at work yesterday and by the time I got home, I was ready to amputate my feet. Then I had to mow and walk a couple miles, so by the time Chris got around to singing, I was only interested in warm water for my lil feet. So I was getting that ready while he sang. But from what I heard, it was just okay. I think he'll be in the bottom 3 this week - unless his girl fans kicked up the votes.
* Haley. THANK YOU HALEY for wearing a shirt. That was a blessing. The shorts - well - Simon was right. She's surviving on looks. I am pretty sure Diana Degarmo sang that same song a couple years ago, and as not great as Diana was, she did a better job than Haley! I couldn't understand her - it seemed like she was running out of breath - probably from trying to sing and wiggle around at the same time. But I wasn't so annoyed with her this week because at least she wore a shirt and at least she didn't smirk and roll her eyes at the judges. I would put her in the bottom 3 too.
* Phil. Though I am still a Phil fan, that was my least favorite performance from him - not helped at all by cracks at the end. He'll probably show up in the bottom 3 again.
* Jordin - I hated her outfit again this week. I didn't think it helped her. But although I hate the song she sang, I actually enjoyed her version of it and thought she sounded really good. She should stay around.
* Blake - my pick for best of the night. He did a SUPER job on that song and he is a good subtle entertainer. He deserves to be in the finals.
* Sanjaya - Once again, I thought he wasn't bad. I thought this was his best performance to date and I actually kind of enjoyed it. He's still not one of my favorites overall, but he's showing much improvement over the others!
8 comments:
Well last night was just okay. I agree overall with your (and Simon's) analysis. I thought he was a bit rougher than necessary with Melinda and I'm glad he pointed out why Haley is still around.
Sadly, I would have to say that Sanjaya actually didn't completely annoy me this week. I think I'd like him a tiny (emphasis on the tiny) bit better if he'd spend less time on his hair and more on being a singer. Still he should definitely NOT win. (Is America reading this?)
I was cheering Simon on during his Haley analysis. He's right on the money. But he was too rough on Melinda. I think she's right - he had desperately wanted to say something bad and finally got his chance!
I was with you on Sanjaya. He really wasn't bad at all. He's improved since the hair got cut. Maybe it was weighing down his vocal cords?
I almost agree totally with you, scary eh? I didn't like the theme either, but I liked the songs weird? I just thought they didn't sing them well. I love JLo though.
My sister is worried this will be the shocker of the season, so I hope she's wrong, my bottom three
Phil, Haley, and Sanjaya(it's time)
going home Phil. Haley is a smart girl, my best is on Haley wearing a bikini next week.
Yes i got the msg from Carly, I gave her some dirt on you so watch out! HAHAHA :)
WHAT?? Dirt? What dirt! You don't have dirt! What did you make up????
HAHAHAHA!! Just wait, Carly and I are conspiring together on this one.
ICK. not a fan of conspiracies.
I am kidding I tried to tell her what a wild child you were in HS, not to believe you if you said otherwise. She laughed and said uhh I know her parents! I was like D'oh!! :)
Yeah I was the wildest of the wilds in high school. LOL. I think that was really YOU. Oh wait - no not really.
Post a Comment