Wednesday, March 25, 2009

Hey I Knew Some Songs!!!

I actually knew three (I think) whole songs tonight! I was so excited! I had to BOOK IT home from church to watch, since the pre-empting (which I am very bitter about and we will not discuss) took place and this got moved to tonight. I am waiting for the show to end so I can go back and watch the first two, but in the meantime, I'll comment on the rest.

Matt: Not too bad. I think maybe better than some of his earlier ones - but I still don't think he's as good as some of the other guys. I think it's good that he went first because had he gone after some of the later ones - might have been rough. The judges called him a front runner but I guess I've not been quite convinced yet.

Kris: Well I think Kris is great and that song was perfect for him. (Incidentally - knew this one too.) Anyway, he's a cutie, he's comfortable in what he wants to sing and I was a huge fan of this one!!

Scott: This is one of the songs I knew! Can't Hurry Love. (Boy isn't THAT the truth. Oh, sorry. I digress.) Anyway, I actually really loved his rendition - but the judges didn't all agree. I was on Kara's side that an up-tempo song from Scott was much needed. This was my favorite one from him so far, but I did not have a lot of company on that opinion from the judges. Was it at this point that Paula crawled under the table? That had me scared for just a minute.

Megan: Okay here's my thing with Megan. She is my Carly of this season. I just can't get into her style and, in fact, she confuses me. The whole time she sang, I thought "Is she even hitting the notes?" but I half expected the judges to praise the daylights out of her performance. I was thrilled to find out I was right and it really was a train wreck. Her voice drivees me nuts. I do think she is stunningly beautiful, but as with Carly - the excessive tattoos paired with an elegant look just doesn't work.

Anoop: I liked last week better from Anoop. I didn't think I liked SO much falsetto from him. Simon cleared it up for me in his comments - Anoop did look kind of bored and asleep while he sang. I thought he did okay as far as the notes and the technicality, but I didn't connect with it at all.

Michael: Church it up? I've never heard a song described that way, but okay. I thought he was better than the judges gave him credit for. I actually liked it better than last week because I could understand the words. Still - I think he's bottom 3 this week. I hope to goodness he survives past Megan, but I'm worried for him.

Lil: This is the first week I've liked her song (maybe because I knew it?). I am a bit worried she's going to get a little Jennifer Hudsonish on me. She has just a bit of attitude and while she managed to keep her opinions to herself a bit more this week than she did last week - I am not sure that the Jennifer side of her is gone.

Adam: Christina, are you ready? I LOVED HIM. He was my favorite performance of the night (assuming the 2 I have yet to watch here in a second don't top his). I was a bit worried the judges would be rough on him for so drastically changing his look - I remember times in the past when they've been upset with people for doing that. But I thought he looked INCREDIBLY handsome all cleaned up and he didn't scare me nearly so much. He can SING. No doubt about that.

Danny: I thought he was very entertaining and engaging - but why didn't he do those lines like he said he was going to? I think he has a lot of good potential not only as a singer but as an entertainer. Some of these people are good singers but their concerts wouldn't be much fun. Can't say that for Danny!

Allison: I didn't like her song until the end when she got so powerful and then she shot straight to second place after Adam. I thought she was amazing - she had NO place in the bottom 3 last time and she better not be there this time.

Bottom 3? Well two of them need to be Michael and Megan. I'm a tiny bit worried for Scott and Anoop too. I want Megan to go home but worry it will be Michael.

9 comments:

Christina said...

Okay, you're going to be impressed because I am actually not going to leave a long comment!

To sum it up...we totally agree.

I knew you would love Adam this week. There is no doubt that he is immensely talented.

Megan annoys the heck out of me (pun sort of intended!) as do her tatoos.

Danny is always great but should have listened to Smokey...still, he'll be fine.

Allison is amazing. I generally don't like the rocker girl, but she's good.

Bottom 3? Michael, Megan and Scott.

I think Megan's going home, but it's really a toss-up between her and Michael.

Bekah said...

I love it when you leave long comments - and i finally could get in to write you back on the one you left me a couple of posts ago.

Any chance that this week's adam will be back again?? If so, I could really like him!!!!

I love it that we agree - must be why we're friends!! :D

Tsofah said...

Bekah:

I agree with you about Megan's voice. It's just all over the place. (I liked Carly MUCH better, except for the Tattoos...)

Danny and Allison were may fav's - with great admiration for Scott.

Sorry, but I can NOT get past Adam's lifestyle choices and femininity. It's the same problem I had with whatshisname that was second runner up with Jordan.

(SIGH) Thank G-d for David Cook last year! and...when is Daughtry gonna record again????? :-D

Bekah said...

Tsofah - I should say that you are 100% right on voices between Carly and Megan. Carly definitely could sing but I was always so distracted by the tattoos that I couldn't focus on the song. Maybe this time I should be glad for the distraction?

I'm not thrilled with Adam's choices either - and I think his look this week helped me forget that for just a second. And for the life of me I can't remember who came in second to Jordin! OH!!!! Was it umm....oh beat box boy. What was his name??? Blake? I can't remember.

Yes - David and Daughtry were two of the great ones. Too bad they didn't have the judge's save Daughtry's year!

Christina said...

Interesting that Daughtry was mentioned.

We bought his album and really liked it. However, I have heard him "live" (on tv) and have been totally unimpressed (as has Andrew). It was pretty bad. I think he must make a much better studio artist than live.

Now David Cook can do no wrong! He is great live and recorded. I can't wait for his next album.

And just to clarify, I really don't know anything about Adam's lifestyle other than the way he dresses. I know what I would guess and that turns me off, but it doesn't change the fact that he is immensely talented.

Bekah said...

Did I know you have seen David live?

Must be something about the name David...and great singers. Smile.

Christina said...

Let me clarify...I have not seen David Cook live in person. Neither have I seen Chris Daughtry live in person.

I've only seen live performances (like on Saturday Night Live) for both guys and a few other live on tv performances.

Now, I did look into David Cook's tour schedule and saw that he was going to be at Valpo, but the tickets sold out before I could get them. Oh well...he's going to be around for quite a while, I think!

Sorry for the confusion...and yes, it must be the name!

Sarah said...

When I saw Adam this week come out looking like a sharp Elvis lookalike, I just KNEW you would see him as an awesome performer! This was a good move on his part, considering how he alienated a lot of Idol fans with his weird "Ring of Fire" performance. He IS a great singer and I think he should win the whole thing. I like how he takes risks but stays true to himself as an artist. I'm SO glad to see Michael to go home - sorry! I thought he was a snooze-fest in his audition, Hollywood week, etc. and I'm still bitter that Alexis (who was WAY better than Michael) went home last week instead of him.

Bekah said...

Christina - ahhhh I gotcha now. I was wondering when I missed your concert-going! My friend Jessica had some pretty great seats (or seets, as I just wrote) at that Valpo concert. I saw her pictures!

Sarah - yes, yes, he won me over. sigh. and i was SO GLAD to see you today!!!